Jean Khoury

Summary: A generation is entering adult life at the moment when the instruments it inherits have begun to perform the intellectual tasks on which careers, identities and a sense of usefulness were built. It cannot see what comes next. Neither can its elders. This article argues that the resulting anxiety is neither unprecedented nor merely pathological. It is the old mal du siècle, the sickness of those who feel born too late, caught between a world that has ended and a world that has not yet appeared, and with no reason to rejoice in what is coming. Musset gave it that name in 1836; Augustine, Pascal, the survivors of the plague and the generation of 1945 knew it under other names. It asks why the postwar generation of the Trente Glorieuses could hope and why that hope has faded. The article examines what foresight is possible, and distinguishes prophecy from prediction. It identifies seven regularities in earlier technological transitions, sets out four trajectories open to the present one, and says plainly what can and cannot be known. It then draws on philosophy, psychology, exegesis and theology to show what the wisdom of the centuries offers to those who must act without a map: hope as a virtue distinct from optimism, the present moment as the place of vocation, birth as a beginning and not an arrival too late. At the summit of hope it sets the journey that no instrument can undertake in our place, the way of purification and grace towards union with God described by Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross, in which love becomes the soul’s only occupation. It examines the counterfeit answers that tempt the young, namely distraction, ideology, techno-messianism and cynicism. It then sets out a vocation proper to this generation, the first to grow up beside artificial intelligence and therefore the first to decide what it is for. The article concludes with practical commitments for young people, for parents and educators, for the Church and for institutions. Its central claim is that the generation which believes it has missed the epic phase of history has been given the task of founding the next one.

Introduction: The Sentence of a Generation

« Le mal du siècle, c’est ça. C’est le sentiment d’être né trop tard, entre deux mondes, d’avoir raté la phase épique de l’histoire et de n’avoir aucune raison de se réjouir du futur. »

That is the evil of the century (the 19th): the feeling of having been born too late, between two worlds, of having missed the epic phase of history and of having no reason to rejoice in the future.[1]

The sentence names three wounds. The first is lateness. The epic seems to belong to someone else, to the builders, the revolutionaries, the founders and the conquerors, and what remains is the administration of their legacy. The second is the interval. The young person stands between a world whose rules no longer hold and a world whose rules are not yet written, so that the advice of parents describes a country that no longer exists. The third is the loss of anticipation. Youth has always been the age of expectation, and a generation that cannot look forward with desire has lost the thing that belonged to it most naturally.

This is the condition of many young people today, and artificial intelligence has made it acute. A student learns a profession and wonders whether it will still exist when he qualifies. A young writer, programmer, translator, analyst or illustrator watches a system perform in seconds what took years of formation to acquire. A generation raised to believe that effort leads to competence and competence to a place in the world now doubts the second link. The anxiety is also an inability to imagine. Nobody can describe with confidence what a good life, a stable career or a family economy will look like in twenty years. The unknown is no longer the ordinary uncertainty of the future. It is a fog over the whole road.

The preceding study, Freed for Ourselves, argued that every technical liberation relieves a burden and demands a new interior effort, and that the history of the self, with its discoveries and its counterfeits, is the record of that effort. This article asks what follows for a generation that experiences the liberation first as a threat. It attempts something that must be done with care, namely foresight. To foresee, in the sense used here, is not to predict. No one knows the speed or the course of what is coming. Foresight of the kind a historian, a philosopher or a theologian can offer is of a humbler and more useful sort. It identifies the regularities of earlier transitions, states the genuine alternatives, separates what can be known from what cannot, and asks what the permanent structure of the human person and the permanent content of the Christian faith imply for those who must act in the meantime.

The argument works at three levels, as before. At the historical level it relies on documented developments and on current evidence, which is provisional. At the philosophical level it interprets. At the theological level it confesses a faith. The purpose is pastoral. It is to put into the hands of those who accompany the young an account of their situation that is honest about the danger, accurate about the past and truthful about the hope.

Part I: The Anatomy of an Anxiety

1. The unknown as the shadow of freedom

Kierkegaard distinguished fear from anxiety. Fear has an object; anxiety has none, or has possibility itself as its object. Anxiety, he wrote, is the dizziness of freedom, which arises when freedom looks down into its own possibility.[2] The distinction matters for the present case. Someone afraid of unemployment can calculate, save and retrain. Someone anxious before a future whose shape is unknown stands at the edge of a possibility too large to grasp. The anxiety is a sign that something is truly open. It is the shadow cast by freedom, and it cannot be removed without removing the freedom. This does not make it comfortable. Dizziness can paralyse. But it gives us a first orientation: the task is not to eliminate the anxiety but to give it a direction.

The historian Reinhart Koselleck supplies a tool for understanding why the anxiety has grown. In every period, he argued, people hold together a space of experience, made of what has been lived and handed down, and a horizon of expectation, made of what is hoped for or feared. In traditional societies the two largely coincided. The son expected to live as the father had lived. In the modern age they separate, and the gap widens as change accelerates.[3] Hartmut Rosa has described how social acceleration produces a world in which the knowledge of one generation loses its value before it can be transmitted, so that we run faster merely to remain in place.[4] Artificial intelligence widens the gap to the point at which the horizon is opaque even to those who build the systems. A young person cannot borrow the future from the elders, because the elders do not have it.

Hannah Arendt opened her reflections on this predicament with a line of René Char: “Notre héritage n’est précédé d’aucun testament.” Our inheritance was left to us by no testament.[5] A tradition passes on possessions and also a will, a statement of what is to be done with them. When the will is missing, the heir inherits a house with no instructions. Arendt called the resulting space the gap between past and future, and she insisted that it is also the place of thought. Those who find themselves in it have no tradition to lean on automatically, and are therefore obliged to think.

A third element, which is particular to our age of machines, was identified by Günther Anders. He spoke of Promethean shame, the shame of the human being before the perfection of what he has made.[6] A person who sees a machine produce a flawless text, an accurate diagnosis or a polished image feels, obscurely, that his own labour is clumsy and obsolete. The feeling is irrational in one respect and perceptive in another. It is irrational because a person is not a producer of outputs. It is perceptive because the culture in which many of us were formed did teach us to measure ourselves by output. The shame reveals the anthropology we had been living by, and AI is making it intolerable.

2. The Romantic precedent

The phrase mal du siècle belongs to the generation that came of age after Napoleon. In La Confession d’un enfant du siècle (1836), Alfred de Musset describes a youth conceived while their fathers were at war, born of anxious mothers into a generation “ardente, pâle, nerveuse”: ardent, pale and nervous. The old world of throne and altar had been destroyed in the Revolution; the epic of the Empire had ended at Waterloo; what remained was a Restoration that looked backward and a future that no one could describe. Musset’s diagnosis is exact: “Tout ce qui était n’est plus; tout ce qui sera n’est pas encore. Ne cherchez pas ailleurs le secret de nos maux.”[7] All that was is no more; all that will be is not yet. Look nowhere else for the secret of our ills. In Rolla he had put the same experience into a line that every later generation has recognised: “Je suis venu trop tard dans un monde trop vieux.”[8] I have come too late into a world too old.

Chateaubriand had named the mood a generation earlier. In the Génie du christianisme he described the vague des passions, the state of a soul that has exhausted the world in imagination before touching it in experience, and so possesses a surplus of desire with no object to receive it.[9] Goethe’s Werther, to which the video refers, belongs to an earlier moment. It was published in 1774, before the Revolution, and shows a sensitive young man whose energy finds no form in the society around him and who consumes himself.[10] The chronology is a reminder that the sickness does not depend on one political event. It appears whenever the inherited forms cease to contain the energy of the young.

The video’s thesis, that Romanticism arose from an incapacity to imagine the future, is suggestive but incomplete. Romanticism had other roots: the reaction against a narrowly rationalist Enlightenment, the discovery of history and nation, the revival of religious sensibility. What the thesis rightly identifies is a common condition. Different Romantics responded to it in four ways.

Some were consumed by it. The melancholy of Werther, the spleen of the poets and the self-destruction of many sensitive young men are real, and they are the lesson of what happens when the energy of a generation has no object. Others fled: into the Middle Ages, into the Orient, into nature, into dream. Some turned to titanism and worshipped the hero, Napoleon or Byron, as a substitute for the epic they had missed. A fourth group did something different. They turned the interior depth that the age had opened into a work. Schleiermacher, writing in 1799 to the cultured despisers of religion, described religion as the sense and taste for the infinite and so reopened for his generation a path that rationalism had closed.[11]Chateaubriand’s apology for Christianity, whatever its literary excesses, helped to rekindle a religious and cultural imagination in France.[12] And the young Frédéric Ozanam, a student at the Sorbonne in the 1830s, was challenged in a debate to show what the Church actually did for the poor. According to the traditional account, he and a few friends answered by going to the poor themselves, and so began the conferences of charity that became the Society of Saint Vincent de Paul.[13] He was twenty. He belonged to the very generation described by Musset.

The same wound therefore produced ruin in some and a lasting work of charity, art and thought in others. What differed was whether the energy had been given an object worthy of it. Even Musset knew this. In La Nuit d’octobre he wrote: “L’homme est un apprenti, la douleur est son maître, / Et nul ne se connaît tant qu’il n’a pas souffert.”[14] Man is an apprentice, pain is his master, and no one knows himself until he has suffered. The sickness of the century was also, for those who endured it well, a school.

3. A succession of generations between two worlds

The condition of being between two worlds is more frequent in history than any generation living through it can suppose. When Alaric’s armies sacked Rome in 410, Christians and pagans alike took the event for the end of the world, and the pagans blamed Christianity. Augustine’s response in the City of God belongs to the permanent literature of consolation, and one of his sermons gives the shortest form of its wisdom. People complain that the times are bad and hard, he says. Let us live well, and the times will be good: nos sumus tempora, we are the times; such as we are, such are the times.[15]A generation cannot stand outside its age and wait for a better one. It constitutes the age.

The Black Death and the century of upheaval that followed gave the late Middle Ages the mood Huizinga described in The Autumn of the Middle Ages, an exhausted, anxious and morbid culture mourning a vanishing order.[16] Yet the same period produced the devotio moderna and the Imitation of Christ, a book of interior discipline written for people who could no longer rely on the grand structures of the medieval world.[17] In the seventeenth century Pascal, confronted with the infinite spaces opened by the new science, confessed: “Le silence éternel de ces espaces infinis m’effraie.” The eternal silence of these infinite spaces terrifies me.[18] He did not answer the terror with a theory of the cosmos. He answered it with the heart, with the wager and with Christ.

The generation of 1918 knew the mal du siècle as the aftermath of a catastrophe that had destroyed the confidence of a civilisation, and Spengler gave it a theory of decline.[19] The generation of 1945 knew it in the shadow of the camps and the bomb. Camus, receiving the Nobel Prize in 1957, put its response in terms that deserve to be quoted whole: “Chaque génération, sans doute, se croit vouée à refaire le monde. La mienne sait pourtant qu’elle ne le refera pas. Mais sa tâche est peut-être plus grande. Elle consiste à empêcher que le monde se défasse.”[20] Each generation doubtless believes itself called to remake the world. Mine knows it will not remake it. But its task is perhaps greater. It consists in preventing the world from falling apart.

Alasdair MacIntyre ended After Virtue with an image drawn from a still earlier collapse. Our predicament, he wrote, resembles the age when the Roman Empire fell. The decisive turning point came when men and women of good will turned from shoring up the empire and set about constructing local forms of community in which the moral life could be sustained. “We are waiting not for a Godot, but for another—doubtless very different—St Benedict.”[21] Romano Guardini, writing in 1950, said that the modern age was ending and that the new age would demand a new kind of person, more attentive, more responsible, more inward.[22]

Two lessons follow. The first is that the feeling of being born too late is itself recurrent, and therefore not an accurate perception of the historical moment. It is a mood of transitions. The second is that the epic is a retrospective genre. Contemporaries of the fall of Rome, of the Revolution and of the great wars did not live in an epic. They lived in confusion, fear and loss, and the epic is the name we give to confusion once it has been survived. The young person who thinks that earlier generations lived in an age of heroic clarity is looking at their monuments and not at their diaries.

4. The hope that was: the Trente Glorieuses and their end

The video makes a contrast that deserves development, because it explains why the present anxiety is so sharp. The generation before ours had a hope, and ours has lost it. The economist Jean Fourastié gave the name Trente Glorieuses to the thirty years from 1945 to the mid-1970s, in which France, like much of the Western world, experienced a sustained rise in prosperity.[23] Thirty years earlier, in 1949, he had published a book whose title states the mood: Le Grand Espoir du XXe siècle, the great hope of the twentieth century, in which technical progress was expected to bring economic and social progress with it.[24] That hope was not naive. It rested on experience.

Why they could hope. The first reason was a visible task. After the devastation of the war there was a country to rebuild, and every person could see what needed doing. The epic that the video says has been missed was in fact the epic of those years, and it is worth noticing what kind of epic it was: reconstruction, the founding of institutions and the patient making of peace. The second reason was that experience and expectation coincided. In Koselleck’s terms, the space of experience and the horizon of expectation were aligned. Each year was better than the last, a child could expect to live better than his father, and generally did. The third reason was institutional. Social security was founded in France in 1945, schooling expanded, employment was high and the gains of the machine were shared. This confirms the first regularity set out in Part II: the golden age was not produced by technology alone but by the institutions built around it. The fourth reason was that science had a good name. Antibiotics, vaccines, electrification, the green revolution and the conquest of space made progress a visible and beneficial force. The fifth reason was a project of peace. The Schuman Declaration of 9 May 1950 proposed that nations which had destroyed one another should build a common future, saying that Europe would not be made all at once but through concrete achievements which first create a de facto solidarity.[25] It is a sentence that Jeremiah would have understood.

Why it faded. The hope has not disappeared everywhere. Across the world poverty and mortality have fallen in the decades since, and many people in poorer countries have more reason for hope than their grandparents had. What has gone is the confident, collective and Western hope in progress. Several causes can be distinguished.

The first is that the growth which sustained it came to an end. The oil shock of 1973 is the usual marker. Mass unemployment, deindustrialisation and slower growth followed, and a society that had come to expect continuous improvement found that the ascent had stopped.

The second is that the generational contract was broken. Studies of income mobility in the United States have found that the share of children who earn more than their parents has fallen from about nine in ten for those born around 1940 to about one in two for those born around 1980.[26] The pattern differs between countries, but the sentiment is widespread: for the first time in generations, many young people expect to do worse than their parents. The mal du siècle has an economic form.

The third is that the costs and limits of progress appeared. Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring (1962) questioned the effects of industrial chemistry.[27] The report The Limits to Growth (1972) suggested that exponential growth on a finite planet could not continue.[28] The nuclear threat, present since Hiroshima, became a permanent background. Hans Jonas’s Imperative of Responsibility (1979) is the philosophical expression of the change: technology is no longer only a promise but a danger that demands a new ethics. Progress, which had been the object of hope, became in part the object of fear.

The fourth is that the great narratives collapsed. Jean-François Lyotard defined the postmodern condition in 1979 as incredulity towards metanarratives.[29] The fall of communism in 1989 removed the last great secular story, and Francis Fukuyama’s essay on the end of history raised the question of what the human being would be without great struggles. His figure of the last man, a comfortable creature with no cause worth dying for, is a near description of the feeling in the video: to have arrived after the epic.[30] The counterfeit vocation of ideology had at least supplied a sense of grandeur. When it fell, nothing replaced it.

The fifth is that the hope had been placed in having and not in being. Even at its height the young could see its hollowness. Georges Perec’s Les Choses (1965) portrays a young couple whose lives are consumed by the desire for objects, and Guy Debord’s Society of the Spectacle (1967) analysed a world in which life was replaced by its representation.[31] In March 1968, two months before the May upheaval, the journalist Pierre Viansson-Ponté wrote in Le Monde an article titled “Quand la France s’ennuie”: when France is bored.[32] The youth of the most prosperous generation in French history revolted from boredom. The Council had said in the same decade that man is more precious for what he is than for what he has, and prosperity had increased possession without answering the question of being. When material growth slowed, the emptiness that it had covered became visible.

The sixth is that the transcendent ground of hope eroded. Benedict XVI shows in Spe salvi that modern faith in progress arose as a substitute for Christian hope, transferring to history what had been hoped for from God.[33] The postwar decades coincided with the beginning of a sharp decline in religious practice across Western Europe.[34] A hope placed in progress and not in God cannot survive the failure of progress, and there was little beneath it to catch the fall.

The seventh is the environment of permanent crisis. The financial crash of 2008, the pandemic, wars in Europe and the Middle East, the climate emergency and the continuous stream of alarming news create a sense that crisis is the normal condition. Rosa’s social acceleration and the attention economy of the digital age intensify it, and comparison through screens makes every young person aware of what others have or have achieved. Artificial intelligence arrives into a generation that has already learned to expect the worst.

What this teaches. Four lessons can be drawn. The first is not to idealise. The golden age had its colonial wars, its nuclear dread, its unnoticed pollution and its exclusions, and the hope was not shared equally. The second is that the hope of the Trente Glorieuses was a forecast and not a virtue. It depended on a curve, and when the curve bent it failed. Aquinas’s analysis applies: hope is directed to a good that is arduous but possible, and a hope that rests on automatic improvement has lost the arduous. This is the difference between a hope and a prediction.

The third lesson is that the golden age was made by institutions. The same pattern is likely to decide the outcome now. The promises of abundance and leisure made on behalf of artificial intelligence repeat the promises of Fourastié and of Keynes. They may be realised or not. If they are, it will be as they were then, through deliberate institutional building, and if they are not, the result will be another Engels’ pause. The fourth lesson is the most important. A generation which grew up with a hope that depended on conditions has been handed a world in which the conditions have changed, and has found that it has no other. The question that Part III addresses is what hope remains when the curve is not guaranteed. The answer is the theological virtue, which does not depend on the curve at all.

Part II: What Can Be Foreseen

5. The limits of prophecy

The honest beginning of any foresight is the record of failure. Keynes predicted in 1930 that his grandchildren would work fifteen hours a week, and the productivity he foresaw arrived without the leisure.[35] Forecasts of the effects of new technologies have been wrong in both directions: the short-term effects are generally overestimated and the long-term effects underestimated, a pattern often attributed to the engineer Roy Amara. Whoever promises a precise account of the AI age should be distrusted, and the young are entitled to distrust him.

The Christian tradition has a useful distinction here. It rejects divination, the attempt to extract the future from signs in order to control it, and honours prophecy, which is the reading of the present in the light of God.[36] Biblical prophecy is rarely a prediction. It is usually a conditional word whose purpose is to change the hearer. Jonah announces that Nineveh will be overthrown in forty days; the city repents, the overthrow does not occur, and the prophet is furious that his prediction has failed.[37] He has misunderstood his office. The prophecy was meant to be falsified by conversion. Foresight of this kind states what will follow if nothing changes, in order that something may. It is the form of foresight offered here.

6. Seven regularities of technological transitions

Predicting the course of artificial intelligence is impossible, but earlier transitions display regularities which are likely to recur. They are offered with differing degrees of confidence.

First, the gains arrive later than the disruption, and institutions bridge the gap or fail to. The economic historian Robert Allen has shown that in Britain real wages stagnated for decades during the early Industrial Revolution while output and profits rose, a period he named Engels’ pause.[38] Carlota Perez has described a recurring pattern in which a technological revolution is first installed amid financial excess and social dislocation, and delivers its broad benefits only after institutions have been rebuilt around it.[39] Karl Polanyi observed that societies subjected to the unregulated spread of markets generate a counter-movement of protection.[40] The lesson is that the transition is the dangerous part, that its victims are not compensated automatically and that the quality of the institutions built in the interval decides who benefits.

Second, tasks go before occupations, and the entry rung goes first. Automation generally removes tasks and recomposes jobs before it removes jobs themselves, and what disappears first is routine work performed by beginners. The Stanford Digital Economy Lab, using payroll data from ADP, found in the August 2026 revision of its study that employment of workers aged 22 to 25 in the occupations most exposed to AI was about 19 per cent below where it would have been had it kept pace with less-exposed occupations, while experienced workers in the same occupations showed no comparable gap. The effect operated chiefly through reduced hiring. The authors themselves describe the results as early and descriptive and not as causal estimates, and they note that the effect weakens when education is controlled for and that some divergent trends predate generative AI.[41] The evidence is provisional and should be held so. It nevertheless names a danger that is structural. Beginners learn by doing the simple tasks that a system can now do. If those tasks are not replaced by something that forms them, the pipeline through which experts are made will thin, and a generation will be told to acquire judgement without being given the occasions to acquire it.

The surveys confirm what the data suggest about mood. The Randstad Workmonitor reported in January 2026 on some 27,000 workers in 35 markets and found Gen Z the generation most concerned about the effect of AI on work and Baby Boomers the most self-assured.[42] The anxiety described in this article is therefore measurable, and it is concentrated where the exposure is greatest.

Third, what becomes abundant loses value, and what remains scarce is ennobled. After printing, the scarce goods were the reliable editor, the good teacher and the discerning critic. After recorded music, the live performance became central. After the factory, the handmade object acquired a new dignity, as the Arts and Crafts movement showed. It is reasonable to expect that as the production of competent text, image and code becomes cheap, the scarce goods will be trust, attestation, presence, responsibility and judgement. The point should be stated carefully. A market premium on the demonstrably human is an economic observation and gives no foundation for dignity. The dignity of the person does not depend on his market value. But it is useful for the young to know that the direction in which the market will probably move coincides with the direction in which the human vocation points.

Fourth, every acceleration provokes a movement towards depth. Polanyi’s counter-movement has cultural and religious forms. The great monastic reforms of Cluny and Cîteaux arose from periods of disorder and of entanglement with worldly power. The Arts and Crafts movement answered industrialisation, and Romanticism answered the collapse of the old order. We should expect, and we are already seeing, movements to protect attention, silence, embodied practice and slow forms of learning. Such movements can be wise or merely nostalgic, and the difference lies in whether they are ordered to a good.

Fifth, counterfeits multiply with the genuine. Walter Benjamin observed that mechanical reproduction withers the aura of the original, the unique presence of a work in time and place.[43] Generative systems carry the point to persons and relationships. Synthetic voices, faces and texts make authenticity a problem. Sherry Turkle’s studies of simulated companionship show a pattern of persons turning to systems that offer the appearance of relationship without its risk, with consequences for the capacity for real conversation.[44] The note Antiqua et nova warns specifically against anthropomorphising AI and against substituting systems for human relationships.[45] We should expect authenticity to become one of the great questions of the coming decades, and the testimony of a real person, who can be held to his word, to become more precious.

Sixth, the deepest effect is on human self-understanding. Freud described the great wounds to human self-love inflicted by Copernicus, Darwin and psychoanalysis. Luciano Floridi has proposed that the information revolution is a fourth such revolution, which removes human beings from the privileged position of the only entities capable of intelligent processing.[46] Whether or not the schema is accepted, the experience it names is real. Each of these revolutions humbled, and each, in the long run, led to a more exact understanding of what the human being is. A Christian can recognise in this a pattern. Teresa of Avila taught that humility is walking in truth.[47] An age that removes our false grounds of pride may thereby return us to our true ones.

Seventh, the search for meaning persists and returns in altered forms. Max Weber, in Science as a Vocation, described the disenchantment of the world, the loss of an order of meaning that science could not replace.[48] Charles Taylor has shown that the modern buffered self, protected from the spirits and powers of an earlier age, is subject to a malaise of its own, a sense of flatness and a cross-pressure between closure and transcendence.[49] Frankl identified an existential vacuum, a pervasive sense of meaninglessness that no material provision cures.[50] There is no reason to think that the age of AI will end the hunger for meaning. There is every reason to think that it will make it more visible.

7. Four trajectories

Regularities do not determine the course. The present transition can be imagined as following one of four trajectories, none of which is pure and all of which can coexist in different places.

TrajectoryWhat it looks likeThe classic warningWhat it forgets
Comfortable driftAbundant services, effortless entertainment, thinning attention; people kept pleasantly occupiedHuxley, Brave New World; Postman, Amusing Ourselves to DeathThat comfort is not the same as meaning, and that a person can be satisfied and unformed
Fearful closureRefusal, nostalgia or control; either a panicked rejection of the new instruments or their use for surveillance and dominationOrwell, Nineteen Eighty-Four; Shelley, FrankensteinThat responsibility for a creation cannot be abandoned, and that fear is a poor architect
IdolatryThe machine as oracle, saviour or successor; hopes for salvation, immortality or perfection transferred to technologyThe Tower of Babel; the critique of progress in Spe salviThat an artefact cannot give what only a Person can give
RecompositionPersons use the freed capacity for formation, care, craft and worship; institutions are rebuilt around human dignityThe monastic and civic renewals after Rome and after the RevolutionNothing is guaranteed; it depends on being chosen

The first trajectory is Huxley’s, in which people come to love their servitude and the technologies that undo their capacity to think.[51] The second is Orwell’s, with the variant that the danger may lie as much in the panic of the frightened as in the ambition of the powerful. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, written in 1818 at the height of the first great industrial transition, is a story about neither the monster nor the science. It is about a creator who flees from his creation and refuses the responsibility that his act has produced.[52] The third is a perennial temptation, in which hopes that belong to God are placed upon an artefact. Benedict XVI’s encyclical Spe salvi examined the modern faith in progress and concluded that science can serve humanity greatly, but can also destroy it, unless it is guided by forces lying outside it.[53] The fourth is the only one that requires effort.

The determining variable is not technical. What decides between these trajectories is the formation of persons: what the young are given to live for, what practices are available to them, which communities receive them and what vision of the human being is held before them. This is why the question is pastoral and educational before it is technological.

8. What can be said with confidence, and what cannot

A calibrated summary is useful.

Reasonable expectationsGenuinely open
AI will be integrated into most knowledge work and many servicesThe speed of capability growth and the limits, if any, of present approaches
Disruption will be uneven, and entry-level positions will be among the first affectedWhether new occupations will appear fast enough, and for whom
Questions of authenticity, trust and attribution will multiplyHow societies will verify and certify what is genuinely human
Institutions will lag behind the technology, and the cost of the lag will fall unevenlyWhether political and legal responses will be wise, timely or just
Movements of resistance and of depth will emerge alongside the technologyWhether they will be wise or merely reactive
The hunger for meaning will not disappearWhether religious and cultural renewal will occur, and in what form

What the left column implies is that a young person can prepare without knowing the future. He can acquire capacities that remain valuable across the trajectories: judgement, the ability to learn, moral seriousness, the capacity for relationship and the habit of attention. What the right column implies is that nobody should claim certainty, and that the open questions are those on which the actions of this generation will weigh.

Part III: The Wisdom of the Centuries

9. What philosophy says to the anxious

The oldest philosophical response to anxiety about the future is Stoic. Epictetus begins his Handbook by distinguishing what is up to us from what is not.[54] Seneca observes to Lucilius that we are more often frightened than hurt, and that we suffer more in imagination than in reality.[55] The counsel has permanent value. Much of the anxiety of the young concerns outcomes that nobody controls, and it is released when attention is returned to what can be done today. The Stoic answer has a limit. It can produce a tranquillity that is indifferent to the world, and it supplies no object of hope.

Aristotle makes a remark in the Rhetoric that bears directly on the present. The young, he says, are full of hope, because they have not yet been often disappointed, and they are high-minded, because they have not yet been humbled by life.[56]Hope is the natural endowment of youth. A generation that lacks it has been deprived of something that belonged to it by nature, and this is the true gravity of the mal du siècle. It is a wound in the young at the point where they are most themselves.

Thomas Aquinas supplies the exact diagnosis. Hope, he teaches, has as its object a future good that is arduous but possible to attain.[57] Two failures correspond to the two qualifiers. When the good appears impossible, the result is despair. When it appears easy, the result is presumption. The situation of the young is a double pressure of exactly this kind. The market tells them that the arduous good, to become competent in a demanding discipline, can no longer be attained, because the machine will do it first. And the same machine offers the shortcut which makes the arduous seem unnecessary. Both pressures destroy the virtue. The task of formation is to restore the sense that the good is arduous and possible: that it will cost effort, and that the effort is worth making and will not be in vain.

The same tradition has a name for the sadness which sees the good and cannot be moved to pursue it. Evagrius Ponticus called it the noonday demon, the demon of acedia, who makes the day seem endless, the place intolerable and the work pointless.[58] Aquinas treats acedia as sorrow at spiritual good.[59] The mal du siècle is in part a form of acedia: an exhaustion that follows from seeing the great goods and doubting whether one can or should pursue them. The old remedy was neither distraction nor argument but perseverance in small, assigned tasks.

Hans Jonas, writing against the background of nuclear and ecological threat, proposed a heuristics of fear. In an age of technologies whose effects are vast and irreversible, he argued, we must allow imagined catastrophe to instruct us, and he reformulated the categorical imperative: act so that the effects of your action are compatible with the permanence of genuine human life.[60] Jonas turns anxiety into responsibility. Fear becomes the teacher of what must be protected and ceases to be the master of what must be done. The young generation, which feels the dread most strongly, is also the generation best placed to take responsibility for what is to be preserved.

The most important philosophical answer to “born too late” comes from Arendt. In The Human Condition she sets against the inevitability of decline the fact of natality, that every human being arrives as a new beginning. “The miracle that saves the world, the realm of human affairs, from its normal, ‘natural’ ruin is ultimately the fact of natality.”[61] She takes the thought from Augustine, who wrote in the City of God that man was created in order that there might be a beginning, and that before him there was no one.[62] A generation is not an arrival at a party that has ended. It is the beginning of something that has not yet existed. The young are not late. They are the point at which the world can start again.

10. What psychology says

Psychology can be heard at several points, within limits. Clinical anxiety is a medical and psychological reality, and a young person whose anxiety is disabling needs professional help and no exhortation. Most of the anxiety described here is not clinical, but it should not be treated lightly, and the Christian tradition has never set grace against therapy.

Erik Erikson identified the central task of adolescence as the formation of identity and named the virtue that emerges from a successful passage: fidelity, the capacity to sustain loyalties freely chosen despite the inevitable contradictions of value systems.[63] Young people need an object of fidelity. They need something, a person, a work, a community, a faith, to which they can bind themselves. A culture that offers only options, and treats every commitment as provisional, deprives them of the very thing through which identity is formed. Psychology can describe the need. It cannot supply the object.

Frankl, who survived the camps, concluded that the primary human motivation is the will to meaning, and that the person who has a why can bear almost any how.[64] The point is practical. Meaning is found chiefly in three ways: in work or deed, in love and encounter, and in the attitude taken to unavoidable suffering. All three remain open in the age of AI. All three require that the person be an agent and not a consumer.

Two further observations are warranted. Studies of well-being repeatedly find that agency, belonging and a sense of meaning are protective, and that passive consumption is not. A young person who acts, however modestly, in the real world, for someone else, with others, is less at the mercy of dread than one who contemplates the future from a screen. And Hartmut Rosa’s concept of resonance, the experience of a world that answers us and with which we are in living relation, suggests that a relationship in which the other can refuse, surprise and require something of us is different in kind from the experience of being served by a system designed to please.[65] That is an interpretation, and it is offered as such, but it explains why the simulated companion leaves a hunger that a real friend satisfies.

11. What the Scriptures say

The Bible is a library of generations between two worlds. Israel is formed in the interval between Egypt and the promised land. The prophets speak at the end of one order and the beginning of another. The New Testament is written by those who believe that one age has closed and another has opened and who do not know the shape of what is coming. Four texts speak directly to the present.

The first is the letter of Jeremiah to the exiles in Babylon. A generation has been torn from its world. Everything that gave its life form has been destroyed, and the future is entirely obscure. The prophet’s advice is neither to flee nor to despair nor to wait. “Build houses and live in them; plant gardens and eat their produce; take wives and have sons and daughters… seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the Lord on its behalf.”[66] Here is a rule of life for the interval: build, plant, marry, pray, and seek the good of the place where you are. The promise that follows, plans for welfare and not for evil, to give you a future and a hope, is addressed to a people who have been told to live ordinary lives faithfully in a time they did not choose.

The second is Qoheleth, who knew that nobody can foresee. “He who observes the wind will not sow; and he who regards the clouds will not reap… In the morning sow your seed, and at evening do not withhold your hand; for you do not know which will prosper, this or that, or whether both alike will be good.”[67] The wise person does not wait for certainty. He sows in the morning and again in the evening, and accepts that the harvest is not his to know.

The third is the question that Mordecai puts to Esther, when she hesitates to act: “Who knows whether you have not come to the kingdom for such a time as this?”[68] The line is the exact reply to “born too late”. A person born at a particular time may be born for it. The time is not an accident that stands between the person and his destiny, and may be the occasion of the destiny. Paul says the same to the Athenians: God has determined the allotted periods and the boundaries of the habitation of the peoples, so that they should seek him.[69] The time and place of a life belong to its vocation.

The fourth is the promise of Joel, taken up by Peter at Pentecost: “Your old men shall dream dreams, and your young men shall see visions.”[70] The sequence is significant. Foresight is divided between the generations. The old dream, which is the work of memory transformed into longing. The young see visions, which is the work of perception directed forward. A people needs both, and a generation separated from its elders loses half its power of sight.

The apocalyptic books, which are often misread as forecasts, are in fact pastoral texts for the anxious. The book of Revelation is addressed to communities under pressure who do not know what will happen to them. Its message is the endurance of the saints and the assurance that Christ holds the scroll of history: “Behold, I make all things new.”[71] It gives no timetable. It gives a person to trust.

12. What theology says

Hope is a virtue and not a forecast. The Christian doctrine of hope separates it from optimism. Václav Havel put the distinction with precision: hope is not the conviction that something will turn out well, but the certainty that something makes sense regardless of how it turns out.[72] Josef Pieper described hope as the virtue of the status viatoris, the state of the wayfarer, who is on the road, not yet at the end and not lost.[73] Gabriel Marcel made hope the mark of homo viator.[74] Benedict XVI observed that whoever has hope lives differently.[75] The hope in question is not that the AI transition will go well. It is that, whatever happens, the human person is created, loved and called, and that Christ has been raised, so that the last word does not belong to any system, to any catastrophe or to death. That hope does not require knowledge of the course. It is not the hope of the Trente Glorieuses, which was a forecast resting on a curve and failed when the curve bent, as Part I showed. The Council confessed as much: “We do not know the time for the consummation of the earth and of humanity, nor do we know how the universe will be transformed.”[76] The Church herself declares that she does not know the course of history. She knows its end, and she knows the One who holds it.

Charles Péguy’s wonder at the virtue of hope remains unsurpassed. Faith does not astonish God, he wrote, nor does charity. “Ce qui m’étonne, dit Dieu, c’est l’espérance.” What astonishes me, says God, is hope.[77] She is the little girl who walks between her two elder sisters and who, in the eyes of the world, is only along for the ride, but without her the other two would not move. It is no accident that a young person at the end of the nineteenth century, in the middle of the century’s sickness, grasped this.

The present is the place of vocation. Matthew records the counsel: “Do not be anxious about tomorrow, for tomorrow will be anxious for itself.”[78] The counsel is not a recommendation of improvidence. Matthew places it in the context of seeking first the kingdom. It is a statement about where action takes place. Jean-Pierre de Caussade called the present moment the sacrament of the present, the place where God gives himself to us in the duty and the circumstance of each hour.[79] Paul speaks of redeeming the time.[80] The Greek word for the opportune moment, kairos, signifies a time filled with the possibility of decision. The anxiety of the future is a way of being absent from the present, and the present is the only place where a vocation can be answered.

The vocation includes the time. Newman wrote with great simplicity: “God has created me to do him some definite service; he has committed some work to me which he has not committed to another.”[81] The sentence, applied to the problem of this article, has a precise consequence. The service for which a person is created is a service in the time in which he lives. The young are asked to answer a call that could be answered at no other moment, in an age that needs exactly the capacities that are now at stake: judgement, presence, fidelity, discernment, love.

Carmel and the unknown. The Carmelite tradition has dealt more directly than any other with the experience of walking without light. John of the Cross taught that to arrive at what one does not know, one must go by a way one does not know.[82] The dark night is neither a malfunction nor a punishment. It is the way by which a person is detached from every support other than God. Teresa’s bookmark, found in her breviary, expresses the same lesson in a few lines: let nothing disturb you, nothing frighten you; all things pass; God does not change; patience obtains all things.[83]

The most relevant figure is Thérèse of Lisieux, born in 1873, who belongs to the century of the mal du siècle and traversed its darkness. She longed for every vocation: to be a warrior, a priest, an apostle, a martyr. The desire for the epic was in her at full intensity. She found the answer in the Pauline passage on the body of Christ and wrote her conclusion: “In the heart of the Church, my Mother, I will be Love.”[84] The epic she had desired was not abolished. It was relocated, from conquest to love, from the spectacular to the hidden, from the century’s great deeds to the fidelity of each hour. In the last eighteen months of her life she also lived, in the darkest form, the unbelief of her age, which she experienced as a wall of fog and as the voice of those who say that there is nothing beyond the present.[85] She held that she was sitting at the table of sinners and unbelievers and praying for them. A young person who feels the nihilism of the century within himself should know that a saint went through it, and that she did not escape it by theory.

The consequence for our subject is clear. The thirst for the epic, which is the secret of the mal du siècle, is not a mistake. It is a true desire misdirected. It is satisfied in the Christian life, but not in the form that was imagined.

13. The constitutive hope: the journey into love

Everything said so far concerns the penultimate. The tasks of governing, witnessing, caring and building are real, and the generation that undertakes them will do well. But hope in the strict sense, the theological virtue, has a different object, and it is here that the argument must come to rest. Benedict XVI wrote that man’s great, true hope, which holds firm in spite of all disappointments, can only be God, who has loved us and continues to love us to the end.[86] A hope placed in a stable career, a successful transition or even a just social order is destroyed by the next disruption. The hope that cannot be destroyed is the hope of union with the One who calls.

This returns us to the question to which the whole history of instruments leads. What remains, when the instruments have taken over what they can, is the person, called by name, made for communion and fulfilled in the gift of self. The more our instruments accomplish, the less we can hide behind our accomplishments, and the more we are brought back to the question that no instrument can answer for us: who are you, and to whom do you belong? The Christian answer is that we belong to the God who has called us by name, and that we become ourselves in the measure that we answer. Yet this answer is not merely intellectual or moral. It opens onto the greatest undertaking of human existence: the spiritual journey towards union with God and the fullness of love.

Two Carmelites have mapped this journey with a precision that no other tradition has surpassed. Teresa of Avila describes the soul as a castle made of a single diamond or of very clear crystal, with many dwelling places and, at the centre, the King.[87] The seven dwellings trace a progressive transformation of the whole person. The soul enters through prayer and above all through self-knowledge, which she holds to be inseparable from humility. It learns perseverance in the second dwelling. In the third it meets the ordered and apparently virtuous life whose danger is comfortable mediocrity. The gifts of prayer begin in the fourth. The fifth is the prayer of union, which she compares to the silkworm that dies in its cocoon in order to emerge as a butterfly.[88] The sixth is the betrothal, with its trials, and the seventh is the spiritual marriage. John of the Cross sings the same journey as a love song. In the Spiritual Canticle the soul, wounded by love, goes out in search of the Beloved who has hidden himself, and the poem moves through searching, betrothal and marriage to the soul’s transformation in love.[89] The traditional names for the stages are the purgative, the illuminative and the unitive. What they describe is a transformation of the whole person, effected through purification and the action of divine grace, and culminating in the union of love with God.

Two features of this journey bear directly on the anxiety of the unknown.

The first is that the dark night is the interior form of not knowing. John of the Cross teaches that the three theological virtues purify the three faculties of the soul: faith darkens the intellect, hope empties the memory and charity purifies the will.[90] The work of hope is on memory. Memory is the faculty that clings to what has been and projects what may come, and these are exactly the two diseases of the mal du siècle: nostalgia for an epic that is past and dread of a future that has no form. The soul purified in hope does not know what is coming, and it has ceased to need to know. It rests in the One who is faithful. Whoever has been formed in this way is not governed by forecasts and is therefore capable of acting under any trajectory. The long school of the night produces the kind of person that the transition requires.

The second is that the journey is a gift consented to and not a product achieved. Teresa and John agree that the soul can only dispose itself: it prays, it perseveres, it renounces what hinders. The union itself is given. Mary at the Annunciation is the archetype of this consent: “Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word.”[91] No one can utter that fiat for another. No artificial intelligence, however advanced, can undertake this journey in our place, consent to grace on our behalf or love God for us. Here the argument of both studies reaches its limit and its summit. Everything else can be delegated. This cannot. The greatest achievement of human existence is not something we can manufacture, delegate or automate. It is to allow God to bring us to the fullness of union with himself.

It will be objected that this belongs to monks and mystics. The Council answered the objection: all the faithful of whatever rank or condition are called to the fullness of the Christian life and to the perfection of charity.[92] The journey is the universal vocation, and Teresa wrote the Interior Castle for her Carmelite sisters, who found prayer difficult. Nor is it an escape from the world. At the summit, in the seventh dwelling, she insists that the purpose of the spiritual marriage is the birth of good works.[93] The tasks set out in Part V, governing, witnessing, caring, building, guarding and transmitting, are therefore not alternatives to this journey. They are its fruits. The person who has begun to be transformed in love governs without domination, witnesses without vanity, cares without condescension and builds without ambition.

This is also the fulfilment of the history traced in the first study. Every technological revolution has relieved humanity of burdensome tasks and invited it to rise towards activities that are more properly human. Artificial intelligence, by taking over a growing share of our intellectual and practical tasks, carries that movement to an unprecedented level. The movement has a summit, and the summit is not greater productivity but deeper love. The challenge is neither to compete with the machine nor to flee it, but to rise higher, towards what only the human person, freely cooperating with divine grace, can accomplish. We are called not merely to do more, to know more or to produce more, but to become more fully what we were created to be: persons capable of receiving and giving the fullness of love.

John of the Cross gives the end of the road in a stanza of the Spiritual Canticle. The soul, having given itself entirely, says that it no longer tends a flock and has no other occupation, for its only exercise is now to love.[94] Here is the answer to the question about work that the age of machines raises. The occupations of the world may be taken over one by one. One occupation cannot be, and it is the one for which the soul was made. Teresa’s bookmark ends with the line Sólo Dios basta: God alone suffices. It is the final ground of hope. A person who has learned that God suffices has nothing left to be anxious about, and is free, with an ordinary and unspectacular freedom, to do whatever the day requires.

Part IV: The Counterfeit Answers

A generation with a thirst and without a source will drink from whatever is offered. Four counterfeits are particularly active.

Distraction. Pascal observed that the unhappiness of man comes from one thing only: that he cannot stay quietly in his own room.[95] He calls the remedy divertissement, which turns the mind from the question it cannot bear to ask. The machines of the present are the most efficient instruments of diversion ever made. They offer the young an endless supply of stimulus that keeps the anxiety at bay and the vocation unheard. It counterfeits rest.

Ideology. The preceding study argued that ideology harvests the human hunger for self-gift and spends it on causes that cannot receive it. The young generation, deprived of the epic, is a natural target. Péguy, who had been a socialist, observed that everything begins in mystique and ends in politics.[96] The causes that offer the young a sense of grandeur, of enemies and of belonging promise to supply what was missed. Some of these causes are worthy in their aims. The test is the one set out earlier: who is treated as a means, whom the cause permits one to hate, what it demands of conscience and in what it hopes. It counterfeits vocation.

Techno-messianism. The promises of those who expect that machines will end suffering, death or scarcity, and who see the human being as a transitional form, belong to the idolatrous trajectory. They offer the young a place in a story larger than themselves. The story is the old one of salvation by knowledge, now furnished with circuits. Spe salvi identified the structure: when progress is separated from the moral growth of persons, it cannot bear the weight of the hope placed upon it.[97] It counterfeits salvation.

Cynicism. For some young people the safest course is to expect nothing, to hold every ideal at a distance and to treat every commitment as naive. Irony protects against disappointment. But it is the posture of someone who has stopped hoping in order to stop being hurt, and Aristotle’s observation applies in reverse. The young who expect nothing have been made old before their time. It counterfeits wisdom.

Each counterfeit imitates a genuine good: rest, vocation, salvation and wisdom. Each is rejected most effectively by the discovery of the real thing.

Part V: A Vocation for the Generation of the Machine

14. Not late but first

The generation now coming of age is the first in history to grow up beside artificial intelligence. It is therefore not the last heir of a finished epic but the first author of a new one. Every previous technological transition was settled over generations by people who did not choose it. This one arrives with a generation young enough to shape its uses and mature enough, in the course of its life, to see the consequences. The phase épique has not been missed. What was epic about earlier ages was the founding of institutions, the bearing of witness and the building of civilisation under conditions of uncertainty. The same task is now set again.

The old epic was an epic of conquest. The new one is an epic of fidelity. It requires the courage to remain human under pressure, to refuse the counterfeits, to build institutions that serve persons, to protect the weak against the consequences of power and to hand on what was received. It is hidden and slow, and it takes the form of vocation more than of adventure. Such is the epic Thérèse discovered, and the monks after Rome, and the students of 1833.

15. Six tasks

The history and the theology above can be gathered into six tasks, each rooted in what the preceding article described as the specifically human.

Governors of power. The systems that will shape the coming decades will be built, regulated and used by people. Someone must ask what these systems are for, whom they serve and whom they harm. Antiqua et nova insists that AI is a product of human intelligence and requires human responsibility in its direction.[98] Jonas’s imperative applies. Law, medicine, engineering, education, finance and public administration will need people who combine competence with the moral formation to ask “for what end?” and who have the courage to say no. This is a vocation for a generation, and it cannot be delegated to the machines.

Witnesses of truth. In a world flooded with synthetic text, image and voice, the reliability of a person’s word will be of exceptional value. The Greek word for martyr is martys, witness. A person who tells the truth at cost, who can be held to what he says, who attests what he has seen and done, has a social function that no system can fulfil. This applies in the courtroom, the newsroom, the laboratory, the classroom and the family. The witness is the guarantor of the real.

Artisans of presence. Simone Weil wrote that attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity.[99] The care of the sick, the teaching of the child, the accompaniment of the dying and the lonely, the work of listening: these are the tasks in which the person, and not the output, is the substance. They are labour-intensive by nature and cannot be mass-produced. They will be among the most needed and the least well recognised, and there is no reason why they should not be the most honoured.

Builders of institutions. Jeremiah’s counsel to build and plant applies to institutions as well as houses. The transition will need new forms of apprenticeship that restore the beginner’s rung, new standards of attribution and verification, new forms of work organisation that share the gains, and new communities in which persons can be formed. Ozanam did not wait for the state or for the Church to resolve the social question. He began a conference of charity. Every institution that now serves the poor, the sick or the student began as the work of a few young people who saw a need.

Guardians of interiority and worship. After Rome, the monasteries preserved learning and prayer and made them the seed of a civilisation. The present age needs places and practices of silence, contemplation and liturgy where persons learn to attend, to be addressed and to receive. These are the conditions of every other task. They are also a form of resistance against the scattering of attention that the instruments encourage.

Transmitters between the generations. Joel’s sentence assigns dreams to the old and visions to the young. The task of this generation includes taking from its elders what is permanent, the wisdom of fidelity, the memory of earlier crises and the practices of prayer, and offering in return the perception of what is new. A generation that rejects its inheritance as obsolete will lose the resources it needs. A generation that clings to its inheritance without perceiving the new will fail its heirs.

16. What the elders owe

The older generations have a duty that is easily neglected. They have no testament to leave in the sense of a complete plan, and they should say so. The false confidence of those who promise that all will be well is as damaging as the despair of those who say that all is lost. The elders can offer something better than prediction. They can give testimony: what fidelity cost, how earlier crises were survived, where they failed. They can admit that they built, or allowed to be built, the world that the young inherit. They can refuse to hand on their own fears, and they can introduce the young to the practices, sacramental, contemplative and communal, through which the Christian tradition has carried people through darkness for twenty centuries. Pope Leo XIV, addressing a conference on artificial intelligence in June 2025, said that the young must be helped and not hindered in their journey towards maturity and true responsibility. He added that authentic wisdom has more to do with recognising the true meaning of life than with the availability of data.[100] That is a succinct statement of what the elders owe.

Part VI: Practical Consequences

The conclusions of the study can be put into practice. They are set out here for different persons.

17. For young people

Accept the interval and refuse the paralysis. Do not wait for the picture of the future to clear. Jeremiah’s rule applies: build, plant, learn, love, pray, seek the welfare of the place where you are. Choose a first step that is small, concrete and within reach.

Learn something deeply. Choose a discipline, a craft or a language and submit to the difficulty of mastering it, even when a system could produce the result. The capacities formed by difficulty, patience, judgement and the ability to recognise error, are what remain valuable whatever the technology does. Use the instruments, but let them serve the formation and not replace it.

Choose one object of fidelity. Bind yourself to a person, a community, a work or a faith. Fidelity is the virtue of youth, and it cannot be practised in the abstract. Make a promise and keep it.

Practise silence daily. Give a fixed period each day to silence, reading and prayer, without a screen. Begin with ten minutes. Lectio divina and the prayer of the heart give attention an object and train the capacity to be addressed.

Begin the journey. Hope has a final object, and the road to it is mapped. Read slowly, and with a guide, the first dwellings of Teresa’s Interior Castle and the opening stanzas of John’s Spiritual Canticle. Pray daily, receive the sacraments and remain faithful when prayer is dry. The journey is not reserved to monks. It is the vocation of every baptised person, and it is the source from which every other task draws its strength.

Find a guide. Seek a spiritual director, a teacher or an older friend who has persevered, and speak honestly with him or her about the fears and the desires. The elders have no map but they have walked.

Serve someone who is poor, sick or alone. Ozanam’s road remains open. Service is the most reliable cure for the sense of uselessness, because it places a person before a concrete need that cannot be handled by a system, and because it teaches the difference between an output and an act.

Limit the noise. Reduce the streams that scatter attention. This is a means to protect the conditions of vocation and is not a moral purity.

Ask the question of vocation. Ask, not what will the machine leave for me, but what am I called to? It is a question to be put in prayer, in the light of Scripture, and with a guide. The answer is rarely dramatic, and it usually emerges through faithfulness in the small tasks of the day.

18. For parents, teachers and formators

Do not transmit your own anxiety, and do not offer false reassurance. Speak honestly about what is unknown. Teach the difference between fear and responsibility. Design education so that it forms understanding, judgement and character and does not merely certify output: oral examination, dialogue, practical work and sustained projects. Protect the experience of difficulty. Give children and adolescents real responsibilities, which make them necessary to someone. Form the habits of attention, of reading and of conversation. Introduce the young to the saints, who are the Church’s witnesses of lives lived in dark times, and to the works of those, from Augustine to Camus, who faced the interval honestly. Teach the journey itself: that every person is called to the fullness of love, that prayer is a school and not a performance, and that the saints are guides who have walked the road. Be present. A young person who is accompanied is less alone in the fog.

19. For the Church and communities of formation

The Church has twenty centuries of experience of accompanying people through ends of worlds, and in the present moment this is among her most precious resources. Communities of formation can offer: places of silence and liturgy; schools of prayer in which lectio divina and the prayer of the heart are taught; spiritual direction available to the young; formation that connects technical competence with moral discernment and with the call to holiness; fraternal life that counteracts isolation; and works of charity in which the young can serve. The Church should speak with honesty about AI, as Antiqua et nova has done, without condemning the instruments and without sanctifying them. She should be a place in which the young hear what no system will tell them: that they are loved, that they are called by name, and that the world needs what they alone can give.

20. For institutions and policy

Protect the entry rungs of the professions. If the work through which beginners learn is automated, institutions have a responsibility to create new forms of apprenticeship, so that the pipeline of expertise is not broken. Support retraining and transitions on terms that preserve dignity. Share the gains of productivity. Require transparency about what is synthetic and what is human. Treat education and the formation of attention as public goods. Let those who will bear the consequences of AI have a voice in its governance. The experience of Engels’ pause is the warning: if the gains are left to arrive by themselves, a generation may pay the price for a benefit that comes to others.

Conclusion

A generation feels itself to have been born too late, between two worlds, with no reason to rejoice in the future. The sentence is true as a description of a mood and false as a description of history. The mood is recurrent. Augustine’s contemporaries, the survivors of the plague, Musset’s generation and the children of 1945 all experienced it, and in each case some of them turned the interval into a vocation. The epic phase of history is a retrospective name for periods of confusion that were survived. It is not a time that has passed.

The foresight that is possible has been set out. We cannot predict the course of artificial intelligence. We can identify the regularities of earlier transitions: that gains arrive late and institutions decide who receives them, that beginners are the first to be displaced, that scarcity moves from the reproducible to the personal, that counterfeits multiply, that human self-understanding is the deepest stake and that the hunger for meaning persists. We can name four trajectories, drift, closure, idolatry and recomposition, and say that the choice among them is a question of formation. We can say what is open. And we can offer what the wisdom of the centuries supplies to those who must act without a map: Jeremiah’s rule of building and planting in exile; Qoheleth’s counsel to sow in the morning and in the evening; Aquinas’s analysis of hope as a good that is arduous and possible; Arendt’s and Augustine’s truth that each person is a beginning; Thérèse’s discovery that the epic is relocated to love; and the Church’s confession that she does not know the course of history but knows its end and the One who holds it.

Beneath every point of the foresight lies the hope that does not depend on it. The person, called by name, is made for communion and fulfilled in the gift of self, and the age of the machine has made this unavoidable. The Christian answer to the question who you are and to whom you belong opens onto the greatest undertaking of human existence, the journey of purification and grace towards union with God that Teresa and John describe. No system can walk it for us, consent to grace in our place or love God on our behalf. Here the technical history and the history of the self arrive together at their summit.

The generation of the Trente Glorieuses could hope because experience and expectation coincided and because institutions shared the gains. Ours has inherited the loss of that hope without the conditions that supported it, and the lesson is that a hope resting on a curve fails when the curve bends. Only the theological virtue survives the bending.

The counterfeits will tempt the young: distraction in place of rest, ideology in place of vocation, techno-messianism in place of salvation and cynicism in place of wisdom. Each can be refused by the discovery of the real thing. What the real thing offers is a name, a task and a communion. The name is given by the God who calls each person. The task is to be the governors, witnesses, artisans, builders, guardians and transmitters that the coming age requires. The communion is with the Church, with the elders who dream and the peers who see, and with the saints who walked through darkness before us.

The machines can write the text, compose the image and calculate the result. They cannot forgive, promise, bear witness or love. The more they accomplish, the more clearly these acts stand out, and the more those who perform them are needed. A generation that supposed itself late has been placed at the beginning of an age whose character is not yet decided. That generation will decide it, and it will do so, as every generation has done, by what it loves and by what it is willing to give. And if it allows God to bring it to the end of the road, it will know in the end what John of the Cross sings: that the soul’s only occupation is to love.

authors themselves describe as preliminary, and should be updated at the time of publication.

Read Also:

Freed for Ourselves: Technological Liberation, the Inward Turn and the Christian Discovery of the Person

The City of God, Understanding Time and History

The Future is Jesus

Mary, the Prophecy

Bibliography

Allen, Robert C. “Engels’ Pause: Technical Change, Capital Accumulation, and Inequality in the British Industrial Revolution.” Explorations in Economic History 46 (2009): 418–435.

Anders, Günther. Die Antiquiertheit des Menschen. Volume 1. Munich: C. H. Beck, 1956.

Aquinas, Thomas. Summa theologiae. I-II, q. 40; II-II, qq. 17–22, 35, 95, 171–174.

Arendt, Hannah. Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought. New York: Viking, 1961.

Arendt, Hannah. The Human Condition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958.

Aristotle. Rhetoric. Book II, chapter 12.

Augustine. Sermons. Sermon 80.

Augustine. The City of God. Books I–V and XII.

Benedict XVI. Spe salvi. 30 November 2007.

Benjamin, Walter. “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction.” In Illuminations. Edited by Hannah Arendt. Translated by Harry Zohn. New York: Schocken, 1969.

Brynjolfsson, Erik, Bharat Chandar and Ruyu Chen. “Canaries in the Coal Mine? Six Facts about the Recent Employment Effects of Artificial Intelligence.” Stanford Digital Economy Lab working paper, 2025; revised 12 August 2026. https://digitaleconomy.stanford.edu/news/canaries-in-the-coal-mine/

Camus, Albert. Discours de Suède. Paris: Gallimard, 1958.

Carson, Rachel. Silent Spring. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1962.

Caussade, Jean-Pierre de. Abandonment to Divine Providence.

Chateaubriand, François-René de. Génie du christianisme. 1802.

Chetty, Raj, et al. “The Fading American Dream: Trends in Absolute Income Mobility Since 1940.” Science 356 (2017): 398–406.

Debord, Guy. La Société du spectacle. Paris: Buchet-Chastel, 1967.

Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith and Dicastery for Culture and Education. Antiqua et nova: Note on the Relationship Between Artificial Intelligence and Human Intelligence. 28 January 2025.

Epictetus. Enchiridion.

Erikson, Erik H. Identity: Youth and Crisis. New York: W. W. Norton, 1968.

Erikson, Erik H. Insight and Responsibility. New York: W. W. Norton, 1964.

Evagrius Ponticus. Praktikos.

Floridi, Luciano. The Fourth Revolution: How the Infosphere Is Reshaping Human Reality. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.

Fourastié, Jean. Le Grand Espoir du XXe siècle. Paris: Presses universitaires de France, 1949.

Fourastié, Jean. Les Trente Glorieuses, ou la révolution invisible de 1946 à 1975. Paris: Fayard, 1979.

Frankl, Viktor E. Man’s Search for Meaning. Boston: Beacon Press, 2006.

Freud, Sigmund. “A Difficulty in the Path of Psycho-Analysis” (1917). In The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works. Volume 17. London: Hogarth Press, 1955.

Fukuyama, Francis. The End of History and the Last Man. New York: Free Press, 1992.

Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von. Die Leiden des jungen Werthers. 1774.

Guardini, Romano. The End of the Modern World. Wilmington, DE: ISI Books, 1998.

Havel, Václav. Disturbing the Peace: A Conversation with Karel Hvížďala. Translated by Paul Wilson. New York: Knopf, 1990.

Huizinga, Johan. The Autumn of the Middle Ages. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996.

Huxley, Aldous. Brave New World. 1932.

John of the Cross. Ascent of Mount Carmel. Books I–III.

John of the Cross. Spiritual Canticle.

John Paul II. Homily at the Beatification of Frédéric Ozanam. Notre-Dame de Paris, 22 August 1997.

Jonas, Hans. The Imperative of Responsibility. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984.

Kempis, Thomas à (attrib.). The Imitation of Christ.

Keynes, John Maynard. “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren.” In Essays in Persuasion. London: Macmillan, 1931.

Kierkegaard, Søren. The Concept of Anxiety. Translated by Reidar Thomte. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980.

Koselleck, Reinhart. Futures Past: On the Semantics of Historical Time. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1985.

Leo XIV. Message to the Second Annual Rome Conference on Artificial Intelligence. 20 June 2025. https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2025-06/pope-leo-on-ai-exceptional-tool-but-cannot-forget-human-dignity.print.html

Lyotard, Jean-François. La Condition postmoderne. Paris: Minuit, 1979.

MacIntyre, Alasdair. After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981.

Marcel, Gabriel. Homo Viator: Introduction to a Metaphysic of Hope. London: Victor Gollancz, 1951.

McLeod, Hugh. The Religious Crisis of the 1960s. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Meadows, Donella H., et al. The Limits to Growth. New York: Universe Books, 1972.

Musset, Alfred de. La Confession d’un enfant du siècle. 1836.

Musset, Alfred de. La Nuit d’octobre. 1837.

Musset, Alfred de. Rolla. 1833.

Newman, John Henry. Meditations and Devotions. 1893.

O’Meara, Kathleen. Frederic Ozanam, Professor at the Sorbonne: His Life and Work. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1876.

Orwell, George. Nineteen Eighty-Four. 1949.

Pascal, Blaise. Pensées.

Péguy, Charles. Le Porche du mystère de la deuxième vertu. 1912.

Péguy, Charles. Notre jeunesse. 1910.

Perec, Georges. Les Choses. Paris: Julliard, 1965.

Perez, Carlota. Technological Revolutions and Financial Capital. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2002.

Pieper, Josef. On Hope. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1986.

Polanyi, Karl. The Great Transformation. New York: Farrar and Rinehart, 1944.

Postman, Neil. Amusing Ourselves to Death. New York: Viking, 1985.

Randstad. Workmonitor 2026, as reported in “Gen Z Fears AI’s Impact More Than Boomers, Randstad Data Shows.” Allwork.Space, 21 January 2026. https://allwork.space/2026/01/gen-z-fears-ais-impact-more-than-boomers-randstad-data-shows/

Rosa, Hartmut. Resonance: A Sociology of Our Relationship to the World. Cambridge: Polity, 2019.

Rosa, Hartmut. Social Acceleration: A New Theory of Modernity. New York: Columbia University Press, 2013.

Schleiermacher, Friedrich. On Religion: Speeches to Its Cultured Despisers. 1799.

Schuman, Robert. Declaration of 9 May 1950.

Second Vatican Council. Gaudium et spes. 7 December 1965.

Second Vatican Council. Lumen gentium. 21 November 1964.

Seneca. Epistulae morales. Letter 13.

Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. 1818.

Spengler, Oswald. The Decline of the West. 1918–1922.

Taylor, Charles. A Secular Age. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007.

Teresa of Avila. The Interior Castle.

Thérèse of Lisieux. Story of a Soul. Translated by John Clarke. Washington, DC: ICS Publications, 1996.

Turkle, Sherry. Alone Together. New York: Basic Books, 2011.

Turkle, Sherry. Reclaiming Conversation. New York: Penguin, 2015.

Viansson-Ponté, Pierre. “Quand la France s’ennuie.” Le Monde, 15 March 1968.

Weber, Max. “Science as a Vocation.” In From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. Edited by H. H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills. New York: Oxford University Press, 1946.

Weil, Simone. Waiting for God. Translated by Emma Craufurd. New York: Putnam, 1951.


[1]Sentence from a French video found on the internet. The sentence is the starting point of the argument and is not offered as a historical source. The video also refers to Goethe’s Werther and to Musset’s Confession d’un enfant du siècle.

[2]Søren Kierkegaard, The Concept of Anxiety (1844), ch. 2, § 2, trans. Reidar Thomte (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980).

[3]Reinhart Koselleck, Futures Past: On the Semantics of Historical Time, trans. Keith Tribe (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1985), especially the chapter “‘Space of Experience’ and ‘Horizon of Expectation’: Two Historical Categories.”

[4]Hartmut Rosa, Social Acceleration: A New Theory of Modernity, trans. Jonathan Trejo-Mathys (New York: Columbia University Press, 2013).

[5]Hannah Arendt, Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought (New York: Viking, 1961), Preface, “The Gap between Past and Future,” quoting René Char, Feuillets d’Hypnos (1946), no. 62.

[6]Günther Anders, Die Antiquiertheit des Menschen, vol. 1 (Munich: C. H. Beck, 1956), on “Promethean shame.”

[7]Alfred de Musset, La Confession d’un enfant du siècle (1836), Part I, chapter 2. The description of the generation as “ardente, pâle, nerveuse” is in the same chapter.

[8]Alfred de Musset, Rolla (1833), Part I.

[9]François-René de Chateaubriand, Génie du christianisme (1802), Part II, Book III, chapter 9, “Du vague des passions”; see also René, originally a part of the work.

[10]Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Die Leiden des jungen Werthers (1774).

[11]Friedrich Schleiermacher, On Religion: Speeches to Its Cultured Despisers (1799), Second Speech.

[12]Chateaubriand, Génie du christianisme. The work’s literary and apologetic influence in post-revolutionary France is widely acknowledged, though its apologetics are criticised for aestheticism.

[13]John Paul II, Homily at the Beatification of Frédéric Ozanam, Notre-Dame de Paris, 22 August 1997, which recalls the origins of the conferences of charity in 1833; see also Kathleen O’Meara, Frederic Ozanam, Professor at the Sorbonne: His Life and Work (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1876). The story of the challenge in debate is the traditional account and should be checked against modern biographies.

[14]Alfred de Musset, La Nuit d’octobre (1837).

[15]Augustine, Sermon 80.8 (Latin numbering); “Bene vivamus, et bona sunt tempora: nos sumus tempora; quales sumus, talia sunt tempora.” On the response to the sack of Rome see The City of God, Books I–V.

[16]Johan Huizinga, The Autumn of the Middle Ages, trans. Rodney J. Payton and Ulrich Mammitzsch (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996; Dutch original, 1919). Huizinga’s interpretation of the period has been much debated.

[17]Thomas à Kempis (attrib.), The Imitation of Christ, composed in the early fifteenth century in the milieu of the devotio moderna.

[18]Blaise Pascal, Pensées, Brunschvicg 206; Lafuma 201.

[19]Oswald Spengler, The Decline of the West (1918–1922).

[20]Albert Camus, Discours de Suède (Nobel banquet speech, Stockholm, 10 December 1957), in Discours de Suède (Paris: Gallimard, 1958).

[21]Alasdair MacIntyre, After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory (Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981), final chapter.

[22]Romano Guardini, The End of the Modern World (1950; English trans., Wilmington, DE: ISI Books, 1998).

[23]Jean Fourastié, Les Trente Glorieuses, ou la révolution invisible de 1946 à 1975 (Paris: Fayard, 1979). The expression is Fourastié’s, and the dating of the period varies between authors.

[24]Jean Fourastié, Le Grand Espoir du XXe siècle: Progrès technique, progrès économique, progrès social (Paris: Presses universitaires de France, 1949).

[25]Schuman Declaration, 9 May 1950, delivered by Robert Schuman, French Foreign Minister: “Europe will not be made all at once, or according to a single plan. It will be built through concrete achievements which first create a de facto solidarity.”

[26]Raj Chetty, David Grusky, Maximilian Hell, Nathaniel Hendren, Robert Manduca and Jimmy Narang, “The Fading American Dream: Trends in Absolute Income Mobility Since 1940,” Science 356 (2017): 398–406. The study concerns the United States; comparable trends in other countries differ and are debated.

[27]Rachel Carson, Silent Spring (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1962).

[28]Donella H. Meadows, Dennis L. Meadows, Jørgen Randers and William W. Behrens III, The Limits to Growth (New York: Universe Books, 1972). The report’s models and conclusions have been much debated.

[29]Jean-François Lyotard, La Condition postmoderne: rapport sur le savoir (Paris: Minuit, 1979), Introduction.

[30]Francis Fukuyama, “The End of History?” The National Interest 16 (1989): 3–18; The End of History and the Last Man (New York: Free Press, 1992). Fukuyama’s thesis concerned the triumph of liberal democracy as an ideology; the figure of the last man draws on Nietzsche.

[31]Georges Perec, Les Choses: Une histoire des années soixante (Paris: Julliard, 1965); Guy Debord, La Société du spectacle (Paris: Buchet-Chastel, 1967).

[32]Pierre Viansson-Ponté, “Quand la France s’ennuie,” Le Monde, 15 March 1968.

[33]Benedict XVI, Spe salvi, §§ 16–23, on the emergence of the modern faith in progress and its displacement of Christian hope.

[34]Hugh McLeod, The Religious Crisis of the 1960s (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007).

[35]John Maynard Keynes, “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren” (1930), in Essays in Persuasion (London: Macmillan, 1931).

[36]Thomas Aquinas, Summa theologiae II-II, qq. 171–174 on prophecy and q. 95 on divination.

[37]Jonah 3:4–10 and 4:1–3.

[38]Robert C. Allen, “Engels’ Pause: Technical Change, Capital Accumulation, and Inequality in the British Industrial Revolution,” Explorations in Economic History 46 (2009): 418–435.

[39]Carlota Perez, Technological Revolutions and Financial Capital: The Dynamics of Bubbles and Golden Ages (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2002).

[40]Karl Polanyi, The Great Transformation (New York: Farrar and Rinehart, 1944).

[41]Erik Brynjolfsson, Bharat Chandar and Ruyu Chen, “Canaries in the Coal Mine? Six Facts about the Recent Employment Effects of Artificial Intelligence,” Stanford Digital Economy Lab working paper, first circulated August 2025, with the revision of 12 August 2026 reporting a 19 per cent relative gap for workers aged 22–25 in the most exposed occupations, based on ADP payroll data through June 2026. https://digitaleconomy.stanford.edu/news/canaries-in-the-coal-mine/. The authors describe the findings as early, descriptive indicators, not causal estimates.

[42]Randstad, Workmonitor (2026), as reported by Allwork.Space, “Gen Z Fears AI’s Impact More Than Boomers, Randstad Data Shows,” 21 January 2026, https://allwork.space/2026/01/gen-z-fears-ais-impact-more-than-boomers-randstad-data-shows/. The report’s sample comprises about 27,000 workers and 1,225 employers across 35 markets. The generational comparison is qualitative in the source consulted.

[43]Walter Benjamin, “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction” (1935–1936), in Illuminations, ed. Hannah Arendt, trans. Harry Zohn (New York: Schocken, 1969).

[44]Sherry Turkle, Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other (New York: Basic Books, 2011); Reclaiming Conversation: The Power of Talk in a Digital Age (New York: Penguin, 2015).

[45]Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith and Dicastery for Culture and Education, Antiqua et nova (28 January 2025), especially the sections on anthropomorphism and on relationships.

[46]Luciano Floridi, The Fourth Revolution: How the Infosphere Is Reshaping Human Reality (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014); Sigmund Freud, “A Difficulty in the Path of Psycho-Analysis” (1917).

[47]Teresa of Avila, The Interior Castle, Sixth Dwelling, chapter 10.

[48]Max Weber, “Science as a Vocation” (1917; published 1919), in From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, ed. H. H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills (New York: Oxford University Press, 1946).

[49]Charles Taylor, A Secular Age (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007), on the buffered self and the “malaise of immanence.”

[50]Viktor E. Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning (Boston: Beacon Press, 2006), on the “existential vacuum.”

[51]Aldous Huxley, Brave New World (1932); George Orwell, Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949); Neil Postman, Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business (New York: Viking, 1985), foreword, contrasting Orwell and Huxley.

[52]Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818).

[53]Benedict XVI, Spe salvi (30 November 2007), especially §§ 16–31 on the modern idea of progress; the statement on science is in § 25.

[54]Epictetus, Enchiridion 1.

[55]Seneca, Epistulae morales 13.4.

[56]Aristotle, Rhetoric II.12, 1389a.

[57]Thomas Aquinas, Summa theologiae I-II, q. 40, a. 1, and II-II, qq. 17–22 on hope, despair and presumption.

[58]Evagrius Ponticus, Praktikos 12.

[59]Thomas Aquinas, Summa theologiae II-II, q. 35.

[60]Hans Jonas, The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of an Ethics for the Technological Age, trans. Hans Jonas and David Herr (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984; German original, 1979), chapter 1 for the reformulated imperative and chapter 2 for the heuristics of fear.

[61]Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958), chapter V, on natality.

[62]Augustine, The City of God XII.20: “Initium ut esset, creatus est homo, ante quem nullus fuit.”

[63]Erik H. Erikson, Insight and Responsibility (New York: W. W. Norton, 1964), chapter 4, on fidelity; Identity: Youth and Crisis (New York: W. W. Norton, 1968).

[64]Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning, in which Frankl cites Nietzsche’s saying about the why and the how.

[65]Hartmut Rosa, Resonance: A Sociology of Our Relationship to the World, trans. James Wagner (Cambridge: Polity, 2019). The application to simulated companionship is the author’s interpretation, not Rosa’s.

[66]Jeremiah 29:5–7 and 29:11.

[67]Ecclesiastes 11:4–6.

[68]Esther 4:14.

[69]Acts 17:26–27.

[70]Joel 2:28; Acts 2:17.

[71]Revelation 21:5; see also Revelation 14:12 on the endurance of the saints.

[72]Václav Havel, Disturbing the Peace: A Conversation with Karel Hvížďala, trans. Paul Wilson (New York: Knopf, 1990), the passage distinguishing hope from optimism.

[73]Josef Pieper, On Hope, trans. Mary Frances McCarthy (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1986; German original, 1935).

[74]Gabriel Marcel, Homo Viator: Introduction to a Metaphysic of Hope, trans. Emma Craufurd (London: Victor Gollancz, 1951; French original, 1944).

[75]Benedict XVI, Spe salvi, § 2.

[76]Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et spes (7 December 1965), § 39.

[77]Charles Péguy, Le Porche du mystère de la deuxième vertu (1912).

[78]Matthew 6:33–34; see also Philippians 4:6–7.

[79]Jean-Pierre de Caussade, Abandonment to Divine Providence, the theme of “the sacrament of the present moment.” The attribution and editorial history of the work are debated.

[80]Ephesians 5:15–16.

[81]John Henry Newman, Meditations and Devotions (1893), “Hope in God—Creator.”

[82]John of the Cross, Ascent of Mount Carmel, Book I, chapter 13, where the saying on the way one does not know is found.

[83]Teresa of Avila, the poem “Nada te turbe,” found in her breviary.

[84]Thérèse of Lisieux, Story of a Soul, Manuscript B, 3v, trans. John Clarke (Washington, DC: ICS Publications, 1996).

[85]Thérèse of Lisieux, Story of a Soul, Manuscript C, 5v–7r, on her trial of faith.

[86]Benedict XVI, Spe salvi, § 27.

[87]Teresa of Avila, The Interior Castle, First Dwelling, chapter 1, no. 1, on the castle of diamond or crystal; chapter 2 on self-knowledge and humility.

[88]Teresa of Avila, The Interior Castle, Fifth Dwelling, chapter 2, on the silkworm.

[89]John of the Cross, Spiritual Canticle, esp. the Prologue and stanzas 1, 14–15 and 22–40 (redaction B). The poem and its commentary describe the soul’s search, betrothal and transformation in love.

[90]John of the Cross, Ascent of Mount Carmel, Book II, chapter 6, on faith, hope and charity as the purifiers of intellect, memory and will; see also Book III, chapter 2.

[91]Luke 1:38.

[92]Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964), § 40, within chapter V on the universal call to holiness.

[93]Teresa of Avila, The Interior Castle, Seventh Dwelling, chapter 4, especially no. 6, on the purpose of the spiritual marriage.

[94]John of the Cross, Spiritual Canticle, stanza 28 in redaction B (stanza 20 in redaction A): “ya sólo en amar es mi ejercicio.”

[95]Blaise Pascal, Pensées, Brunschvicg 139; Lafuma 136.

[96]Charles Péguy, Notre jeunesse (1910).

[97]Benedict XVI, Spe salvi, §§ 16–31.

[98]Antiqua et nova, the passages on AI as a product of human intelligence and on responsibility for its direction.

[99]Simone Weil, letter to Joë Bousquet, 13 April 1942, in Correspondance; see also Waiting for God, trans. Emma Craufurd (New York: Putnam, 1951).

[100]Leo XIV, Message to the Second Annual Rome Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 20 June 2025, reported by Vatican News: https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2025-06/pope-leo-on-ai-exceptional-tool-but-cannot-forget-human-dignity.print.html